Guidance for Local Returning Officers administering a Police and Crime Commissioner election in England and Wales

You should adjudicate doubtful ballot papers regularly as the count proceeds: you should not leave this until the end of the count. 

You should have regard to the Commission’s booklet on doubtful ballot papers throughout the adjudication process. The booklet contains examples of allowed and rejected votes and the key principles to be followed in the adjudication of doubtful ballot papers and can be accessed from our resources page for this section.

You can also find examples of allowed and rejected ballot papers on the doubtful ballot paper placemat, which you should have on display at the count for candidates, agents and observers to refer to. 

Adjudicating doubtful ballot papers

When adjudicating doubtful ballot papers, you should:

• always be clear and consistent
• take time to ensure that a considered decision is given in every case
• determine whether the intention of the voter clearly appears on the ballot paper

As part of this, you will need to:

• consider the whole of the ballot paper
• consider whether the way a ballot paper has been marked means that a vote for one candidate is clearly apparent

Rejected ballot papers

The legislation provides that you must reject a ballot paper which:1  

• does not bear the official mark (not the unique identifying mark)
• votes are given for more than one candidate 
• on which anything is written or marked by which the voter can be identified (except the printed ballot paper number or other unique identifying mark)
• is unmarked 
• is void for uncertainty2

However, the legislation states that unless the way the ballot paper is marked identifies the voter, a ballot paper on which the vote is marked in the following ways must not be rejected if the voter’s intention is clear:3

• elsewhere than in the proper place
• otherwise than by means of a cross, or
• by more than one mark

In addition, ballot papers may require further consideration where there is:  

• anything unusual about it (for example, any ballot paper that appears to have been altered, either with a clearly different writing instrument or with correction fluid)
• any tears or damage to the ballot paper

Ballot papers that are torn or damaged are able to be accepted as a valid vote as long as the paper still contains the official mark and the intention of the voter is clear and none of the other grounds for rejection apply. 

You can find further information in our guidance on how to deal with cut ballot papers at postal vote openings.

You must decide on the validity of all doubtful ballot papers in the presence of candidates, agents and observers. 

Those that are subsequently declared as valid must be counted and included in the total number of votes cast for the appropriate candidate.4

Recording rejected ballot papers

Your decision on any question arising in respect of a ballot paper is final and can only be challenged by way of an election petition.5

You must draw up a statement showing the number of ballot papers rejected and for what reason.6  You should therefore have a system in place throughout the adjudication process for sorting the rejected ballot papers into the following headings:  

• want of official mark
• voting for more than one candidate
• writing or mark by which voter could be identified
• unmarked
• void for uncertainty

You should have regard to the Commission’s guidance and any additional guidance issued by the PARO to ensure accurate and consistent categorisation of rejection for reporting on the statement. 

You must ensure that you mark each rejected ballot paper with the word ‘rejected’7  and must add the words ‘rejection objected to’ if a counting agent objects to your decision.8

Although observers should be able to observe this process, unlike agents, they do not have the legal right to object to the rejection of a ballot paper.

You should place a copy of the rejection statement in the package for rejected ballot papers.